Rule Submission Title | Eliminate contradiction between Rule 10.B and Rule 10.H.1. regarding when a Medical Time out can be taken |
---|---|
USAP Board Vote | Failure Confirmed |
USAP Rules Committee Vote | Failed |
USAP Rules Committee Vote Reason | There is no conflict in the existing rules. The last sentence in 10.H.1 applies to 'time-outs' generally and therefore includes medical time-outs. |
Existing Rule # | 10.B and 10.H.1. |
Proposed Rule Change | 10.B. Medical Time-Out. A player needing medical attention during a match should request a medical time-out from the referee. Once the medical time-out has been requested, the following guidelines shall be used: 10.H.1. 10.H.2 Time-out(s) and Medical Time-Out(s) may be used before the start of the second and subsequent games in a multiple-game match. The current 10.H.2 should be renumbered to 10.H.3. |
Original Rule Text | 10.B. Medical Time-Out. A player needing medical attention during a match should request a medical time-out from the referee. Once the medical time-out has been requested, the following guidelines shall be used: 10.H.1. Before a Match or Between Games: Neither medical nor regular time-outs may be taken before a match starts. A match cannot begin until all players are present and the starting score is called. Time-out(s) may be used before the start of the second and subsequent games in a multiple-game match. |
Reasoning Behind Suggested Change | This change will eliminate the contradiction between current Rule 10.B. Rule 10.B. Clearly states that a medical timeout can be taken anytime ‘during a match’; since there are no exclusions specified. Clearly the time in between games is ‘during a match’. Rule 10.H.1. contradicts Rule 10.B. inferring that a only regular time outs can be taken in between games. There is certainly a chance that a player can cramp up or have other serious medical needs in between games and per 10.B. is allowed to take a Medical Time out. This rule change aligns 10.H.1 with 10.B removing the contradiction. If this rule change is accepted, Referee Handbook Section 5.E.1. Medical Time-Out should be updated as follows: 1. Medical Time-Out [Rule 10.B] |
Rule Book Year | 2024 |
Rule Change ID | 1122 |
Date Created | April 30, 2023 |
View Comments | View Comments |
Recent Comments