Displaying 1 - 3 of 3

Results

Entries
 Rule Change ID Submitted From Comment
2788June 8, 2026Rick

I agree with this change, as mentioned in the scenario, a player can take advantage of this rule to stop play as soon as they feel a rally isn't going their way.

2788June 10, 2026Michele

Agree 100% with this rule change. Both for reasons outlined by author for consistency between stopping play for player position and for erroneous score call. In fact, given that an erroneous score call could also be directly related to or cause a player position error (they can easily occur simultaneously), the rule related to when stoppage of play is allowed should match / be consistent; and as Rick pointed out, so players that are aware of a position error, do not have option to wait and see how a rally is playing out before stopping the rally when it is not going in their favor. Example: Team A is aware they were in the wrong positions, but wait until a lob is going over their heads (ball is still live) that they can't get to that ball, to stop the rally for their player position error.

2788June 13, 2026Alan

I agree with the proposed change for all of the reasons stated as well as the unfair advantage given to a team that realized there was an incorrect position or server and elected to not make the call until just before their opponent was preparing to win the rally with an easy “ put away.”

 Rule Change ID Submitted From Comment